Bruce Gilden’s street shooting methods polarise opinion. His “ambush tactics” (for want of a better phrase) are, for some, the exercise of any photographer’s right in public space, for others he just goes about stuff in a rude way.
Anyway, here’s a TMZ-style photo exclusive of Gilden in front of the camera and not behind it. Gilden the ambushed; not Gilden the ambusher.
Journalist Jake Warga made these photographs in April. Warga was not part of Gilden’s entourage. We can presume that Gilden, at this time, was shooting Haiti: 15 Months Later.
I was critical of Gilden in the aftermath of the Haiti earthquake suggesting his images were little more than a digitised freak-show.
Warga was not surprised the Haitian, who he described as “drunk out of his mind on cheap wine” was attracted to the documentary film crew following Gilden through the graveyard with their photo accoutrements.
“He wanted his photo taken,” says Warga, “I try not to be seduced by spectacle but it was the only way he’d leave me alone. In turn, he gravitated towards Gilden’s cameras, joining the circus of gazes already in Bruce’s orbit.”
The bizarre nature of this interaction can be put down to a mixture of grief, inebriation, intrusion, Gilden’s personal theatre, and the scene acted out by the Haitian man. And all this in a cemetery.
This is probably just another day at the office for Gilden who makes a habit of hanging out with violent persons.
Confusing layers here no doubt, but for me, the take away is Gilden’s flitting averted eyes (top image). As if part of some karmic return, this Haitian man getting up in Gilden’s grill can be read as a metaphor; as a spectre, and brief embodiment, of Gilden’s many victims down the years.
The tables are turned and it looks briefly unsettling doesn’t it?
3 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 29, 2011 at 2:28 am
Markham
Whatever about how he approached his subjects, are his photos not pretty much lacking in technique? I see bad focus, poor composition, lack of thought. This may mark me as a philistine, but his photos fail to take me on a journey.
August 3, 2011 at 7:49 am
Sean
What I absolutely love about BG’s in haiti is that it’s the same as his NY Street work. Its honest and people allow him to’ invade’ their space an and use his flash directly. He goes in hard and fast, sure, but it’s honest and thats what counts most. Composition, yeah sure, people could argue the virtues of lighting and composition and all that but after a while that stuff just doesn’t matter. BG made the best work in Haiti post quake (and before it too!)
August 4, 2011 at 3:39 pm
petebrook
Sean. I see your point. If Bruce treated others with some semblance of respect then he’d be accused of being a fraud. At least he’s consistent in his questionable behaviour! And yes, he’s honest. I just cannot see how he isn’t still a bit of a nuisance.